New Survey Finds Most Americans Agree Certain Plaintiff Lawyer Tactics Increase the Cost of Consumer Goods, Including Insurance

WASHINGTON &ndash; The American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA) and Munich Reinsurance America, Inc. (Munich Re US) today released survey results on consumer attitudes about certain plaintiff lawyer tactics, including excessive lawyer advertising, generating nuclear jury awards, engaging in hidden third party litigation funding (TPLF), and jury anchoring. 

The online <a class="fc-#0563c1 td-underline" href="https://www.apci.org/attachment/static/11220" style="">survey</a>, conducted by The Harris Poll among more than 2,000 U.S. adults, revealed a majority are not familiar with the terms &ldquo;jury anchoring&rdquo; (75%) and &ldquo;TPLF&rdquo; (70%). Once informed, 69% believe the practices of TPLF and jury anchoring will increase the overall cost of home, auto, and business insurance for all Americans, and 66% agree that these tactics will also increase the cost of everyday items, including consumer goods.

The other key findings of the survey show:

<a class="fc-#0563c1 td-underline" href="https://instituteforlegalreform.com/issue/trial-lawyer-advertising/" style="">Lawyer Advertising</a> and <a class="fc-#0563c1 td-underline" href="https://instituteforlegalreform.com/research/nuclear-verdicts-an-update-on-trends-causes-and-solutions/" style="">Jury Awards</a>

<ul class="mb-16" style="">
	<li style="">67% agree that state and federal lawmakers should put restrictions on lawyer advertising to ensure that they&rsquo;re not misleading consumers and to help reduce the number of lawsuits filed.</li>
	<li style="">68% agree that the advertising of verdicts with [purported] large payouts desensitizes people to high jury awards.</li>
	<li style="">68% agree that excessively high jury awards (e.g., nuclear verdicts &ndash; those above $10 million) will increase the overall cost of home, auto, and business insurance for all Americans.</li>
</ul>

Third Party Litigation Funding (<a class="fc-#0563c1 td-underline" href="https://www.apci.org/attachment/static/10668" style="">TPLF</a>) &ndash; funding from outside investors not directly involved in a lawsuit in return for a portion of the jury award

<ul class="mb-16" style="">
	<li style="">77% agree that allowing foreign investors (i.e., outside of the U.S.) to be third party investors in civil claims and litigation in the U.S. could present a threat to national security.</li>
	<li style="">78% agree that allowing foreign investors in civil claims and litigation in the U.S. should be prohibited.</li>
</ul>

<a class="fc-#0563c1 td-underline" href="https://instituteforlegalreform.com/blog/what-are-nuclear-verdicts/#:~:text=Another%20tactic%20is%20jury%20anchoring,leads%20to%20a%20nuclear%20verdict" style="" target="_blank">Jury Anchoring</a> &ndash; lawyers suggest an exorbitant award amount that is often unsubstantiated, which serves as a baseline amount for a jury award

<ul class="mb-16" style="">
	<li style="">75% agree that the practice of jury anchoring will increase the size of jury awards.</li>
	<li style="">84% agree that plaintiff lawyers should support their suggested damage awards with factual evidence.</li>
</ul>

APCIA and Munich Re&rsquo;s <a class="fc-#0563c1 td-underline" href="https://www.apci.org/attachment/static/9657/" style="">first survey</a>, released in early 2024, emphasizes 86% of respondents agree that state and federal lawmakers should address abuses of the legal system and 88% believe there should be full transparency and disclosure of all the parties with a financial stake in a civil lawsuit.

Bonnie Guth, Head of Government Affairs, Munich Re America Services, said, &ldquo;As an industry, it is important to raise awareness and provide education on how these legal practices impact not only the insurance industry, but ultimately the end consumer. Allowing this abuse of the legal system to remain unchecked, it will likely persist and send improper signals to jurors, judges, and defendants about the value of damages. In turn, this can lead to higher insurance costs, financial strain on insurers and reinsurers, depletion of municipal resources, and disincentives for businesses to take risks.&rdquo;

Stef Zielezienski, Executive Vice President and Chief Legal Officer, APCIA, added, &ldquo;The misuse of the legal system fueled by plaintiff lawyer tactics, including misleading legal advertising, excessively high jury awards, third party litigation funding, and jury anchoring, have promoted a litigious culture, which ultimately contributes to rising costs. This unchecked surge of litigation has had a far-reaching economic impact, <a class="fc-#0563c1 td-underline" href="https://www.uschamber.com/lawsuits/hidden-costs-lawsuits-grow" style="">costing</a> the U.S. economy an estimated $529 billion and each household over $4,200. Reforms are needed to reduce consumer costs and improve insurance availability and affordability. The majority of Americans agree that these tactics are driving up insurance costs. We need state and federal policymakers to address legal system abuse to restore fairness and predictability of justice in the United States.&rdquo;

This survey was conducted online within the United States by The Harris Poll on behalf of APCIA from September 26-30, 2024, among 2,090 adults ages 18+. The sampling precision of Harris online polls is measured by using a Bayesian credible interval. For this study, the sample data is accurate to within &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;+/- 2.5 percentage points using a 95% confidence level. For complete survey methodology, including weighting variables and subgroup sample sizes, please contact APCIA.

Munich Reinsurance America, Inc. (&ldquo;Munich Re US&rdquo;) is one of the largest reinsurers in the United States. We provide reinsurance coverages, specialty reinsurance, and risk management solutions to commercial and personal lines insurance carriers, agents and brokers, program administrators, and managing general agents. Our admitted and non-admitted insurance company affiliates offer specialty insurance products. We provide insurance carriers with white-label products to help protect against the devastating effects of natural catastrophes and emerging risks. We believe that by looking out for our clients&rsquo; best interests with innovative risk solutions, we can help build more resilient communities and close insurance gaps.&nbsp;

APCIA and Munich Re US released survey results on consumer attitudes about certain plaintiff lawyer tactics, including excessive lawyer advertising, generating nuclear jury awards, engaging in hidden third party litigation funding (TPLF), and jury anchoring. 

Service Contract Reimbursement--Commercial

FOR RELEASE ON RECEIPT

Contact:

Eileen Gilligan

Priority Issues

Contact